Row of stone columns above wide granite steps on a classical public building

Service · Choosing a 1031 company

1031 Exchange Company: Intermediary, Advisor or Both

Most people who search for a 1031 company mean the intermediary. Some mean the firm that finds the replacement, and a few firms offer both. Here is how to tell which one you are speaking to, how each is paid, and what to check before you sign.

The short answer

A 1031 exchange company is usually a qualified intermediary: the independent firm that holds your sale proceeds under a written exchange agreement so that you never touch them. The term is also used for advisors and securities brokers who design and source the replacement, and some groups do both through related businesses. Every deferred exchange needs an intermediary; an advisor is optional. Breakwater Exchange is the advisor and broker, not the intermediary, and neither role has to be local to you.

Three kinds of firm use the name, and the regulation requires only one of them

The intermediary is the one the tax rules ask for. Reg. section 1.1031(k)-1(g)(4) defines it as a person who is not you or a disqualified person and who, under a written agreement with you, acquires the property you sell, transfers it to the buyer, acquires the replacement and transfers it to you. Without one, or one of the regulation's other safe harbors, money from the sale that reaches your hands ends the exchange.

The advisor or broker is the second kind. It decides with you what the proceeds should buy, how the loan you pay off gets replaced, and how the purchase closes in time. When the replacement is a Delaware statutory trust interest, that firm has to be a broker-dealer or work through one, because the interest is a security. The third kind is the combined group: an intermediary that sits beside a sponsor, a bank, a title company or a brokerage under the same ownership. Our guide comparing the four categories of intermediary scores each against six written criteria; this page is about deciding which of the three kinds you are hiring for which job.

What the intermediary company does, and the two places its income comes from

The intermediary's work is custody and paperwork. It signs the exchange agreement, takes the assignment of your sale contract, receives the proceeds at closing, receives your signed identification by day 45, and wires the money to the replacement closing or to the trust's sponsor. Paragraph (g)(6) of the same regulation requires the agreement to bar you from receiving, pledging or borrowing against the money before the exchange period ends.

It earns money two ways. The first is its fee. The second is the interest on your funds: under Reg. section 1.468B-6, unless the agreement pays all earnings to you, the funds are treated as a loan from you to the facilitator and the earnings are its own. On a large exchange held for months, that clause can matter more than the fee.

The federal rule does not say how the money must be safeguarded. Washington's statute is blunt about the gap: RCW 19.310.040 makes every facilitator disclose that exchange facilitation services are not regulated by any agency of the state of Washington or of the United States government, and requires a fidelity bond of at least $1,000,000 or a qualified escrow in its place. How funds have been lost before, and the account structures that prevent it, are in how exchange funds are protected; the checklist itself is in how to choose a safe qualified intermediary.

What the advisor or broker company does, and how to check one

The advisor works on the replacement side: the equity figure, the debt figure, the income you need, and which structures can deliver them inside 180 days. Where that means a DST interest, the person presenting it must be a registered representative. FINRA's BrokerCheck report shows the firms a representative is or was registered with, ten years of employment history, current registrations or licenses, and any customer disputes or disciplinary events. Search the person and the firm before you send a closing statement.

A broker that recommends a private placement also owes you an investigation of it. FINRA Regulatory Notice 23-08 reminds member firms that they must conduct a reasonable investigation of any security they recommend, including Regulation D offerings, covering the issuer, its management, its assets and its intended use of proceeds, and that they should not rely solely on the issuer's own representations. Ask any advisor what that investigation covered for the offering in front of you.

The broker is paid by the sponsor out of the offering, on terms printed in the private placement memorandum. You do not write it a cheque. Our DST broker page sets out the registrations in detail, and 1031 exchange advisor explains the planning work that comes before any offering.

Firms that do both: four questions before you accept the convenience

One group handling custody and the replacement can save a phone call, and it also puts two different incentives under one roof. These four questions separate the roles again.

  • Is the intermediary a separate legal entity with its own bond, errors and omissions policy and account in your name?
  • Does the advisory side earn more if you choose a trust from an affiliated sponsor than from an outside one?
  • If you decide against the group's recommended replacement, will the intermediary still wire to the property or trust you choose?
  • Can you keep the advisor and use an intermediary from outside the group, or the reverse?

We keep the roles apart by design. We do not hold exchange funds, we do not run trusts of our own or steer clients into in-house products, and we review offerings from eight vetted national sponsors. Step 3 of our process coordinates identification with whichever intermediary you choose and introduces you to one if you have none.

Do you need a 1031 exchange company near you? No, but your property's state sets the intermediary's rules

Nothing in section 1031 or its regulations asks the intermediary or the advisor to be local. The agreement is signed, the identification is delivered and the funds move by wire, so a firm in another state can serve you as well as one across town. What does depend on place is the state statute, and it follows the property you are selling, not the firm's address or yours.

Maine shows how the scope works. Its section 1396 bars anyone from acting as an exchange facilitator in the state without a license, then exempts a qualified intermediary that holds funds from the sale of property located outside Maine. Most of the other statutes are drawn the same way: they attach when the relinquished property sits in the state or when the firm keeps an office there, and a replacement purchase in the state does not by itself bring them in. Nine states have one. Each link goes to the intermediary section of that state's 1031 page.

  • Nevada: license from the Division of Financial Institutions, $1,000,000 bond and $250,000 errors and omissions cover.
  • Maine: license from the Superintendent of Consumer Credit Protection, $250,000 bond or escrow and $100,000 errors and omissions cover.
  • Idaho: escrow agency license, which the Department of Finance applies to intermediaries handling Idaho sales.
  • California: no license; $1,000,000 bond, deposit or qualified escrow, $250,000 errors and omissions cover.
  • Colorado: no license; bond and insurance, with two-signature control of funds above $250,000.
  • Connecticut: no license; bond or a two-signature account, $250,000 errors and omissions cover.
  • Oregon: no license; $1 million in bonds or deposits, or a two-signature escrow, plus $250,000 cover.
  • Washington: no license; $1,000,000 bond or qualified escrow, $250,000 cover, and a printed notice that the service is unregulated.
  • Virginia: no license or bond; a separately identified account and $250,000 errors and omissions cover.

In the other 41 states no statute governs the intermediary at all, so the contract you sign is the whole of your protection. The state also matters at the closing table: several states withhold income tax from a sale unless an exchange exemption is filed in time, and states that withhold at closing lists the forms. For the advisor, the test is registration rather than distance; this firm is licensed in all 50 states and works by phone and video.

How one sale moves between the two companies

Before closing, you sign the intermediary's exchange agreement and assign the sale contract to it, and the advisor works out the equity and debt figures from your settlement statement. At closing the buyer's money goes to the intermediary. In the weeks after, the advisor reserves equity in the offerings that fit, and you sign the identification and deliver it to the intermediary before midnight on day 45.

Then the paperwork crosses over. The sponsor's subscription documents go to you through the advisor, the intermediary receives the wiring instructions, and it sends the funds directly to the trust; our process puts that step at three to five business days in many cases. Your CPA reports the exchange on Form 8824 with the return for the year of the sale. The intermediary timeline and documents guide lists every form on the custody side, and 1031 exchange services lays out who handles the rest.

Tell us which company you already have, and we will fill in the rest

If an intermediary is already chosen, give us its name and we will work alongside it. If not, say so and we will introduce one before your closing. Either way, the proposal needs your closing date, the loan payoff, your adjusted basis, the property's state and your own, and the income you want from the replacement. What a free proposal contains shows what comes back, and a free consultation is the faster route if your closing is close.

Questions sellers ask about 1031 exchange companies

Is a 1031 exchange company regulated?

Not federally. No federal agency licenses intermediaries, and Washington makes every facilitator print that its services are not regulated by any agency of the state or the United States. Nine states have their own statutes; two of them, Nevada and Maine, require a license, and the rest set bond, insurance or account rules.

Should I hire a 1031 company in my own city?

Location matters less than the statute that covers your sale. The state rules attach to where the property you sell is located, so a Nevada sale needs a Nevada-licensed intermediary wherever that firm's office is. Everything else is done by signature and wire, and both the intermediary and the advisor can work with you remotely.

Can the company holding my proceeds also pick my replacement?

Some groups offer both through related businesses. The intermediary's legal job is custody and documents; it is not a securities firm unless it is also registered as one. If one group does both, ask how each side is paid and whether you can keep the advisor and use a different intermediary.

What does a 1031 exchange company charge?

An intermediary charges a fee set in its exchange agreement and may keep the interest on your funds unless the agreement pays it to you. An advisor that places a DST interest is paid by the sponsor from the offering, disclosed in the memorandum. Our page on what a 1031 exchange costs lists the intermediary ranges.

Is Breakwater Exchange a 1031 exchange company?

We are the advisor and securities broker half of the term, not the intermediary. We design and place the replacement, keep the identification and funding on schedule with your intermediary, and introduce you to one if you need it. We do not hold exchange funds.

I already chose an intermediary. Do I need an advisor company as well?

Only if you want help with what to buy. Many sellers buying a single building they found themselves need just the intermediary, a CPA and their agent. An advisor earns its place when the replacement is a DST or a mix of structures, or when the debt figure is hard to cover.

Have an intermediary already? Good. Now plan the replacement.

Send the basics of your sale and the name of your intermediary, if you have one. An advisor will reply with the structures that fit and how the funds will move.

Ask for a proposal for your exchange

Tell us where your sale stands and an advisor will reach out to arrange the first conversation. Based in Irvine, California. Licensed in all 50 states; we work with sellers everywhere by phone and video.

Are you an accredited investor?

Generally, net worth over $1 million excluding your primary residence, or income over $200,000 ($300,000 with a spouse) in each of the last two years.

What do you want from the replacement property?
Best way to reach you

No obligation. A Breakwater Exchange advisor reviews every request personally.

Want a fixed time? Book a consultation and choose your window.

DST marketplace · Preview

See what a DST replacement property looks like

Three of twelve sample structures: asset class, leverage, minimum and hold. The sponsor, the distributions paid and the offering size are what marketplace access adds, after a short suitability call. Request access and the current list follows.

Self Storage Portfolio

Florida and Georgia · Southeast

Climate-controlled storage facilities in high-growth suburbs, with month-to-month leases that reprice quickly.

Minimum
$50,000
Leverage
Moderate leverage40 to 55% loan-to-value
Target hold
5 to 7 years
Strategy
Current income, Growth
Sponsor
Distributions
Offering size

Shown with marketplace access

Sample offering: a hypothetical illustration of this structure type, not an actual or current offering.

Grocery-Anchored Shopping Center

Carolinas · Southeast

A neighbourhood center anchored by a regional grocer, with a mix of national and local in-line tenants.

Minimum
$50,000
Leverage
Moderate leverage40 to 55% loan-to-value
Target hold
7 to 10 years
Strategy
Current income, Diversification
Sponsor
Distributions
Offering size

Shown with marketplace access

Sample offering: a hypothetical illustration of this structure type, not an actual or current offering.

Regional Distribution Center

Interstate logistics corridor · Southeast

A single-tenant logistics building on a long net lease to an investment-grade shipper, held without debt.

Minimum
$100,000
Leverage
All-cash0% loan-to-value
Target hold
7 to 10 years
Strategy
Current income, Diversification
Sponsor
Distributions
Offering size

Shown with marketplace access

Sample offering: a hypothetical illustration of this structure type, not an actual or current offering.

Sample offerings: hypothetical illustrations of structure types, not actual or current offerings. Photos are representative of each asset class. Current offerings are private placements for accredited investors, described by private placement memorandum.

Free, no obligation

Get a free 1031 proposal for your sale

Tell us what you are selling and when it closes. After a short first call, the proposal sets out:

No obligation. A Breakwater Exchange advisor reviews every request personally.