The short answer
When you sell several rental houses you can put them all into one exchange or give each its own. In one exchange, the 45-day and 180-day periods for every house run from the first closing, and the 200 percent identification limit is measured against all the houses combined. In separate exchanges, each house gets its own clocks and its own identification list, which protects a sale that closes months later at the cost of more paperwork. Most landlords also leave a few houses out entirely: the ones that would sell at a loss, and the ones with too little gain to justify the cost.
At a glance
| One exchange, several sales | Both periods run from the earliest transfer, Reg. section 1.1031(k)-1(b) |
|---|---|
| Separate exchanges | Each house has its own 45 days, 180 days and identification list |
| 200 percent rule | Measured against the combined value of every house in the same exchange |
| Loss houses | Section 1031 recognizes no loss, so a house below basis is usually sold outright |
| Reporting | A summary Form 8824 with an attached statement may cover several exchanges |
| Same taxpayer | Houses in different names or partnerships cannot share one exchange |
| Direct title security range | The firm sources single properties between $250,000 and $500,000 |
One exchange suits houses that close within days of each other; separate exchanges suit closings spread over months
Reg. section 1.1031(k)-1(b)(2)(iii) says that when one deferred exchange includes more than one relinquished property and they transfer on different dates, the identification period and the exchange period are both measured from the earliest transfer. A landlord who signs one exchange agreement covering five houses therefore starts every clock the day the first deed records, whatever happens to the other four.
Hypothetically, three houses close on March 1, April 15 and June 30 under one agreement. Identification is due April 15, the day the second house closes, and every replacement must be received by August 28. The June house has not even sold when the list becomes final, and its money must buy something already named and close within two months.
Run the same three sales as three exchanges and each gets its own calendar. The June 30 house would have until August 14 to identify and December 27 to close, with nothing borrowed from the March sale. If your closings cluster within a week or two, one agreement is simpler; if they are spread over a season, separate agreements usually are.
Separate exchange agreements give each house its own clocks, its own list and its own release date
The qualified intermediary holds each exchange's money under an agreement that, under paragraph (g)(6) of the same regulation, bars you from receiving, pledging or borrowing against it until the agreement allows. In a single exchange covering several houses, all of the proceeds sit under one set of those limits. In separate exchanges, each pot follows its own rules, so a house whose replacement falls through does not hold up the money from a house that completed.
The cost is administrative: one agreement, one assignment and one identification letter per house, and usually one fee per exchange. Ask your intermediary in advance how it charges for a set of related exchanges, and read what the intermediary does on your timeline before the first listing goes live.
Separate exchanges can still buy into the same replacement. Two exchanges can each acquire an interest in one Delaware Statutory Trust, provided each names it on its own list and the subscription documents show which exchange paid for which interest.
Identification across several sales: who counts toward the 200 percent rule
Reg. section 1.1031(k)-1(c)(4) allows three replacement properties of any value, or any number whose total value at the end of the identification period does not exceed 200 percent of the aggregate value of all the relinquished properties, measured as of the dates they were transferred. In one big exchange that aggregate is every house combined, which makes a long list of small trusts or houses easier to fit. In separate exchanges each house has its own three names or its own 200 percent ceiling.
A landlord consolidating five houses into one fourplex can live with the three-property rule in a single exchange. A landlord spreading proceeds across several trusts with different minimums often needs the 200 percent rule, and the combined base is a reason to keep those sales together. How to identify replacement property covers the wording of the list itself.
Reporting follows the structure you choose. The Form 8824 instructions allow a summary Form 8824 with your own attached statement when you made more than one exchange, and they treat the transfer of several properties within one exchange as a multi-asset exchange, so tell your preparer which of the two you ran.
Not every house belongs in the exchange: sell the loss houses and the thin-gain houses outright
Section 1031(a)(1) says no gain or loss is recognized on a qualifying exchange. A house worth less than its adjusted basis, perhaps one bought at a peak or one with a large recent remodel, loses its loss if it goes through the exchange. Sold outright, a rental held more than a year generally produces a section 1231 loss, which can offset ordinary income in a year when your section 1231 losses exceed your section 1231 gains.
Houses with a small gain are the second group to test. An exchange costs intermediary fees, possibly a sponsor load on a trust, and a 45-day search, and the saving is the tax on that one house's gain. A house that has been rented for two years with $30,000 of gain may be better sold and taxed; one held for twenty years with most of its value in gain almost never is. Sell or exchange: the numbers shows the comparison.
Suspended passive losses add a third test. If a house is its own activity, a fully taxable sale of it releases that activity's suspended losses under section 469(g), while an exchange carries them forward. Ask your CPA how your returns group the houses before choosing which to exchange.
Title decides who the taxpayer is, so houses held in different names cannot share one exchange
The taxpayer who sells must be the taxpayer who buys. Houses held personally, in a revocable trust you control, or in single-member LLCs you own are usually one taxpayer for exchange purposes because those entities are disregarded. Houses held in an LLC with your spouse or a partner are owned by a partnership, which is a different taxpayer, and those houses need their own exchange. The same-taxpayer rule and drop and swap strategies explain the fixes, which take time and should start before any house is listed.
Houses you bought to renovate and resell are a different problem. Property held primarily for sale is excluded by section 1031(a)(2), so a landlord who also flips should keep those houses out of the exchange and read dealer status and your exchange.
Houses in more than one state bring more than one closing form and more than one tax return
A portfolio spread across states means each closing follows that state's withholding rule and exemption form, filed on that state's deadline. The states that withhold at closing list shows which forms apply and when. Some states also keep track of gain you defer out of them; California's annual FTB 3840 filing continues for as long as the deferred California gain stays deferred, even after you move the money into property elsewhere.
Plan each house's closing date around the clock you chose. In one exchange, a slow closing in one state can push that house's money into a window that has almost run out.
A worked model: five houses, three exchanged and two sold
Hypothetical, round figures. A landlord owns five houses in one name and plans to sell them between March and August. The decision is made house by house, then the exchanged houses are grouped by closing date. Have your CPA check the basis, depreciation and state figures before you commit to any of it.
- House A: sells for $420,000, adjusted basis $140,000. Large gain; exchange.
- House B: sells for $380,000, basis $120,000. Large gain; closes the same week as A, so A and B share one exchange.
- House C: sells for $450,000, basis $470,000 after a 2024 remodel. A loss; sell outright and keep the section 1231 loss.
- House D: sells for $300,000, basis $270,000. A $30,000 gain; sell and pay the tax rather than pay exchange costs.
- House E: sells for $510,000 in August, basis $160,000. Large gain on a late closing; its own exchange with its own clocks.
- Result: about $1,310,000 of sale price exchanged across two agreements, with each pot free to land in trusts, a fourplex or a direct title security.
Where several houses usually go: trusts that end the repair calls, or one larger property that keeps them
Landlords selling a group of houses tend to fall into two camps. Some want fewer roofs: one fourplex or a small building, still managed, but with one insurance policy and one tax bill. Others want no roofs at all. For the second group, interests in several traditional DSTs spread the equity across sponsors and property types, and the firm's page lists minimums of $100,000 to $250,000 per trust. A trust interest cannot be sold on a market, the sponsor decides when the property is sold, payments can shrink or stop, and the money invested can be lost in part or in full.
A landlord who wants to keep a deed can look at a direct title security: a single leased home held through your own single-member LLC, sourced by the firm in the $250,000 to $500,000 range, so each exchanged house can become one replacement house without the tenant calls. Where a single apartment building is the thing being sold, the questions change, and selling an apartment building covers them; if one of your houses is a furnished nightly rental, selling an Airbnb or vacation rental covers the personal-use rules.
Before the first house lists, send us the list with expected prices, loans and closing months. The grouping decision is cheap to make early and expensive to undo after the first deed records, and what a free proposal contains shows how we lay the choices out.
Related questions
Can I sell my first house now and decide later whether the others join the exchange?
You can sell the first one under its own exchange agreement and open separate agreements for the others as they go under contract. What you cannot do is add a later house to the first exchange without its clocks being measured from the first closing.
Do I need a different qualified intermediary for each house?
No. One intermediary can run several exchanges for you, each under its own agreement. Keeping one firm makes the identification letters and the closing instructions consistent.
Can two of my exchanges buy into the same DST?
Yes, as long as each exchange names the trust on its own identification list and buys its own interest with its own money. The subscription paperwork should show which exchange funded which interest.
One house is in my name and one is in an LLC with my brother. Can they share an exchange?
No. The LLC with your brother is a partnership and a separate taxpayer. Your house and the LLC's house need separate exchanges, and your brother's choice of cash or exchange is made at the LLC level unless the title is restructured first, as one partner wants cash explains.
Is selling all my rentals at once a red flag for dealer status?
Selling long-held rentals does not by itself make you a dealer; what counts is why you held them. Houses bought, renovated and resold quickly are the ones that raise the question, and they should stay outside the exchange.
Sources
Checked against these publications on November 8, 2026. Rules and figures change; confirm the current version with your CPA or attorney before you act. This page is general information, not tax or legal advice.
- 26 U.S.C. section 1031, Exchange of real property held for productive use or investment
- Treas. Reg. section 1.1031(k)-1, Treatment of deferred exchanges (multiple relinquished properties, identification, safeguards)
- IRS, Instructions for Form 8824 (multiple exchanges; multi-asset exchanges)
- 26 U.S.C. section 469, Passive activity losses (disposition of entire interest)
- 26 U.S.C. section 1231, Property used in the trade or business



