The short answer
Sell while the lease still has enough term left for a buyer to price and finance it, or after the tenant has committed to a renewal, and avoid being forced to sell in between, when the term is short and the tenant's plans are unknown. A buyer of a single-tenant building is buying the remaining rent, so every year that runs off the lease moves more of the price toward what the building would be worth empty, and the renewal option usually belongs to the tenant, not to you. Whichever path you take, the building is real property you can exchange, and owners tired of single-tenant rollover often move into trusts that hold many leases, such as a traditional DST, so that no single tenant's decision sets their income.
At a glance
| What exchanges | Land, building and the lease interest are all real property under Reg. section 1.1031(a)-3 |
|---|---|
| Renewal options | Usually the tenant's to exercise; count on one only when the written notice arrives |
| Lease buyout money | Hort v. Commissioner: a payment to cancel a lease stands in for rent and is ordinary income |
| Vacant building | Still held for investment, so still exchangeable, but you now carry every expense |
| DST trustee limits | Rev. Rul. 2004-86: the ruled trust could not renegotiate its lease or sign new tenants |
| Tax deferred | Up to 25% on depreciation taken, 15% or 20% on the rest, and 3.8% NIIT where it applies |
| DST minimums | The firm's traditional DST page lists $100,000 to $250,000 per trust |
There are three ways out of a short lease; the bad one is being forced to sell in between
An owner whose single tenant has a few years left has three real choices. Sell now, with the remaining term as the asset. Wait until the tenant exercises a renewal option or signs an extension, then sell with fresh term. Or let the lease run out and either re-lease the building to a new user or sell it empty. Each can work, and each can end in a 1031 exchange.
The outcome to avoid is selling under pressure in the gap: the term is short, the tenant has not said whether it will renew, and a loan is maturing or a partner wants out. That is when a buyer has the most reasons to discount and the fewest reasons to hurry. Mapping the lease's notice dates, the loan maturity and your own deadlines on one calendar is the first job, well before you list.
The asset-level rules for selling a net-leased building, including tenant rights of first refusal and how a loan assumption can eat into your exchange windows, are on the single-tenant NNN property page. This page is about the timing decision when the lease itself is running out.
Every year that runs off the lease moves the price from the rent toward the empty building
A buyer of a single-tenant property is buying an income stream with a known end date and an uncertain afterward. With many years left, most of the price rests on rent the tenant is contracted to pay. As the end approaches, more of it rests on what happens next: months of vacancy, the cost of fitting the space out for someone else, leasing commissions, and the property taxes, insurance and maintenance the tenant has been paying under the net lease and will stop paying when it leaves.
Financing tightens the same way. Lenders size loans against the income they can count on, so a short remaining term can shrink the loan a buyer can get, and that shrinks the pool to buyers with more cash. Fewer bidders and more risk to price is why a building with a short term often sells for noticeably less than the same building with a long one, even though the rent is identical today.
Where the rent sits against the market changes the direction. If the tenant pays more than the space would lease for today, a renewal at a market rate or a vacancy both cut value, and selling with term left captures the higher rent. If the tenant pays less, a vacancy may let you re-lease at a higher rent, and a buyer who sees that may pay for the upside.
A tenant can go dark long before the lease ends, and a buyout payment is rent, not sale proceeds
Read the lease for what the tenant may do before expiry. Many net leases let the tenant close the store and keep paying rent, often called going dark, with no duty to operate. A dark building still collects rent, but buyers price it as a vacancy that has already begun: the tenant has shown it does not need the location, and an empty building on a busy road is not maintained or watched the way an open one is. Check too whether the lease gives the tenant a right to terminate early or a right to buy.
If the tenant offers to pay you to end the lease early, that payment is not part of a sale. In Hort v. Commissioner, the Supreme Court held that an amount a landlord received for cancelling a lease was a substitute for rent and ordinary income. It is taxed when received and cannot be placed in an exchange, although the building itself, sold later, still can. Our page on an expiring ground lease covers the same point for a landlord of land.
Public tenants describe their store closing and relocation plans in their annual reports, which are on the SEC's EDGAR system. Reading your tenant's latest annual report before you decide how long to wait costs nothing.
Selling after a renewal restores the term, at a price set by the renewal rent
A renewal option fixed in the original lease, or an extension the tenant signs now, gives a buyer years of contracted rent again. The questions are what rent the renewal carries and what it costs you to get it. A fixed option rent written a decade ago may sit below today's market; an extension negotiated now may require you to fund a remodel allowance, a new roof or parking lot work as the price of the tenant's signature.
Money you spend to secure the extension comes from your own funds and is added to the building's basis; it cannot come from the proceeds of a sale that has not happened. Ask the tenant early, before the notice window the lease sets, so you know which path you are on while there is still time to choose another.
If the tenant renews and you then sell, the exchange is the same as for any net-leased building. If the tenant declines, you are in the third path, with the advantage of knowing it a year or more before the keys come back.
If the tenant leaves, the empty building is still exchangeable, but carrying it eats the equity
A building that has lost its tenant is still held for investment, so it remains exchange property under section 1031(a)(1), and the land, the building and any new lease interest are real property under Reg. section 1.1031(a)-3. What changes is your cash flow. With no tenant paying the net lease, you pay the property taxes, insurance, utilities, security and upkeep, and a re-leasing effort brings tenant improvement and commission costs on top.
The buyers for an empty single-tenant building are different too: owner-users who want to occupy it, developers who see another use for the site, and investors who plan to re-lease it themselves and price that risk in. Selling empty is a legitimate path when the market for the site is strong. It is a poor one when it is simply where the calendar left you.
Worked model: a $2,400,000 drugstore with 30 months left and a $900,000 loan maturing with it
The figures are hypothetical and rounded, and the price is an assumption, not an estimate of what such a property is worth. You bought a single-tenant drugstore in 2014 for $1,800,000, of which $1,200,000 was building, and have taken about $370,000 of depreciation, so your adjusted basis is about $1,430,000. A buyer offers $2,400,000, selling costs are $100,000, and the $900,000 loan, which matures at about the same time as the lease, is paid off.
Without an exchange, the $870,000 gain is taxed in layers: about $370,000 of depreciation at up to 25 percent under section 1(h), or $92,500; $500,000 at 20 percent, or $100,000; and, if the 3.8 percent tax in section 1411 applies, about $33,000 more. That is roughly $225,500 federal before state tax.
With an exchange, about $1,400,000 of equity goes to the intermediary, and the replacement must cost at least $2,300,000 with $900,000 of debt or added cash, because Reg. section 1.1031(d)-2 treats the payoff as money received. The loan's maturity is part of the reason to decide now: refinancing a building with two years of term left is harder than replacing the debt inside an exchange. Your CPA should check these layers against your own depreciation schedule.
- Gain at stake: about $870,000, roughly $225,500 of federal tax at the top rates.
- To defer it all: at least $2,300,000 of replacement, with $900,000 of debt or added cash.
- Equity to place: about $1,400,000.
Moving from one tenant to many changes the rollover risk, and a single-tenant trust does not
The reason to leave a single-tenant building is usually that one tenant's decision can take your income to zero. A traditional Delaware Statutory Trust that owns several properties, or a portfolio of trusts across sectors, spreads that decision across many leases. The firm's traditional DST page lists minimums between $100,000 and $250,000 per trust, so $1,400,000 can be split across several, with one carrying enough non-recourse debt to cover the $900,000. The cash out DST, the firm's zero cash flow structure on long-term net leases with high leverage and no current distributions, is another way to place the debt side.
Check how a trust handles its own lease rollover. In Rev. Rul. 2004-86, the ruling that lets a trust interest count as real property, the trustee could not renegotiate the lease or enter into leases with other tenants except in a tenant bankruptcy. A trust holding one net-leased store with a few years left faces the problem you are leaving, with less power to solve it; our answer on the springing LLC explains the usual fallback. The trade-offs between owning a net-leased building and owning a trust interest are on our DST versus NNN property page.
Trust interests are securities for accredited investors: illiquid, sold when the sponsor decides, with distributions that can be reduced or stop and principal that can be lost. Diversifying across tenants lowers the chance that one decision empties your income; it does not remove market risk.
What to send us before the renewal notice date
Send the lease or a summary of it, with the expiry date, renewal options and their rents, notice deadlines, and any rights to go dark, terminate early or buy; the current rent; the loan balance and maturity; your purchase price and depreciation schedule; the property's state and yours; and the income you want. A free proposal sets out what selling now would put at stake and the structures that fit the equity and the debt.
If the renewal notice deadline is close, book a free consultation and we will go through the three paths against your calendar. If a buyer is already under contract, read our page on setting up the exchange before closing; if your single tenant leases a warehouse rather than a store, our page for industrial building owners covers the buyer's environmental and loan timeline.
Related questions
My tenant has not said whether it will renew. Should I ask before listing?
Yes. You cannot make it commit before its notice date, but its answer, or its refusal to give one, tells you which path you are on. A buyer will ask the same question in an estoppel certificate.
The tenant moved out last month. Is the building still exchange property?
Yes. A vacant building held for investment or for re-leasing qualifies as relinquished property. The vacancy affects the price and your carrying costs, not whether the exchange works.
The tenant offered to buy out the rest of the lease. Can that money go into my exchange?
No. Under Hort v. Commissioner a lease cancellation payment substitutes for rent and is ordinary income in the year received. Only proceeds from selling the real property can go through the intermediary.
Is a DST that owns one net-leased store safer than my building?
Not on rollover. A single-tenant trust carries the same lease-expiry risk, and its trustee has fewer options than you do. Diversification comes from trusts that hold many tenants or several properties.
My loan matures the same year the lease ends. What does that change?
It makes refinancing harder, because lenders size loans to the remaining term. In an exchange, the payoff becomes debt you must replace with new debt or cash, which a financed trust can cover without a new personal loan.
Sources
Checked against these publications on November 8, 2026. Rules and figures change; confirm the current version with your CPA or attorney before you act. This page is general information, not tax or legal advice.
- 26 U.S.C. section 1031, Exchange of real property held for productive use or investment
- Treas. Reg. section 1.1031(a)-3, Definition of real property
- Hort v. Commissioner, 313 U.S. 28 (1941)
- IRS, Rev. Rul. 2004-86, Delaware statutory trust interests as replacement property
- Treas. Reg. section 1.1031(d)-2, Treatment of assumption of liabilities
- 26 U.S.C. section 1(h), Maximum capital gains rate
- 26 U.S.C. section 1411, Net investment income tax



